The Silence Behind the Door
Vicdan – the Azerbaijani word for “conscience” —serves as the starting point for this column by Abil Hasanov. His writings interpret literature and philosophy as forms of self-affirmation and resistance: against dogma, against power, and against intellectual complacency. The focus is on thinkers and poets whose work affirms the unity of conviction and existence. Criticism appears here as a precise form of judgment—and as a practice of intellectual freedom.
When Maxim Gorky wrote the following words, he had no idea that one day, it would be power itself that would put him to the test:
“Man—that sounds proud!”
If his entire body of work had to be summarised in a single sentence, it would probably be this.
In Gorky’s literature, a person may go hungry, sleep on the streets, be humiliated, beaten, and marginalised by society. Yet even after all that, an inviolable space remains within them: dignity.
This is what Gorky believed.
But did he remain true to this belief until the end of his life?
This is precisely where the real question begins. And it is from such questions, rather than the answers, that conscience begins.
+++
Gorky did not learn about poverty from books.
His childhood was hard. He worked in a wide variety of jobs, travelled around Russia, and lived among the marginalised. The workers, beggars, vagrants, and homeless people who later populated his works were not, for him, inhabitants of a foreign world. He did not write about them with condescension. He himself had once been one of them.
Perhaps this is the source of the enduring power of his literature: one can destroy a person, but not the idea of humanity.
Yet history sometimes confronts a writer with his own words. Even Gorky was not immune to this.
+++
After the Revolution of 1917, his relationship with the Bolsheviks was uncomfortable.
Gorky was alarmed by the violence, the treatment of the intelligentsia, and the destruction of culture. He openly criticised some of the actions taken by the new regime. Then he left Russia.
He lived abroad for years. The years in Italy, particularly those in Sorrento, formed a distinct chapter of his life.
Then he returned. His return was not the typical homecoming of a writer.
Gorky had long since become more than just a writer.
He was a household name.
An authority.
A symbol.
People gathered to welcome him. The regime, too, understood full well the significance of this return.
For a dictatorship needs more than just silent writers.
Sometimes it needs even more urgently a great writer who speaks for it.
An imprisoned writer can be dangerous. But a famous writer on the side of the authorities is more useful.
His reputation then no longer belongs solely to him. The authorities begin to use this reputation as their own voice.
+++
This is exactly where Gorky’s life under Stalin becomes complicated.
He was accorded great honour; his books were published, his name exalted—he was presented as one of the greatest figures of Soviet culture.
But outward deference does not necessarily mean freedom.
The walls of privilege do not protect a person—they merely conceal them.
You do not go hungry there. You don’t freeze. You aren’t beaten.
There may be a guard standing at the door. But one day, you're no longer sure: is the guard protecting you, or actually preventing you from leaving? Perhaps the most dangerous relationship between power and the intellectual lies precisely here. You can see the walls of a prison. You cannot see the walls that privilege erects.
+++
In May 1934, Gorky’s son Maxim Peshkov died suddenly.
He was only thirty-six years old. This death was one of the hardest blows of Gorky’s life.
Later, allegations surfaced that his death was not natural. The investigative and court records from the Stalin era, relating to the death, contain statements regarding the possible involvement of the former NKVD chief Genrikh Yagoda and several individuals from Gorky’s circle.
But here, history compels us to exercise caution. Confessions from the time of the Great Terror cannot be accepted as indisputable truth. Therefore, it cannot be asserted as a proven fact that Maxim Peshkov was deliberately murdered by the regime.
Yet doubt remains.
And sometimes doubt itself is the crucial question of history. Was the death of Gorky’s son merely a family tragedy? Or was it part of the ever-tightening, invisible circle closing in on the great writer?
We may never know the definitive answer to that.
But another truth remains: to intimidate a person does not always require a direct threat.
A person’s most vulnerable spot is often not their own life. It is the people they love.
+++
When we look at Gorky from this perspective, we no longer see simply “the writer who served the regime” or “the victim of power.”
Such simplistic judgments make history easier to grasp.
But they do not do justice to the man himself.
Before us stands a man who lived amid fame, faith, political hope, privilege, fear, family tragedy, and moral responsibility.
This does not absolve him of responsibility. On the contrary—it compels us to think more seriously about responsibility.
For conscience is not merely a concern of the free individual. Conscience is also a concern of the person who is afraid.
+++
One of the most difficult moral chapters in Gorky’s life is his 1929 trip to the Solovetsky Islands camp.
There, he was presented with a specific image. The Soviet camp system was portrayed as a place where people were “re-educated.”
Gorky wrote about what he saw in line with the positive image the regime sought to convey.
This is precisely where another responsibility of the writer begins: What does "seeing" mean? To see what is right before one’s eyes? Or to be suspicious of what is presented to one as an image?
Sometimes the authorities don’t even have to lie to the writer. They simply show him what he is supposed to see.
The clean room.
The neatly made bed.
The contented prisoner.
The prepared answer.
Then the door closes.
The writer leaves.
The truth remains on the other side of the door.
At such a moment, the writer’s task is not merely to look.
It is to doubt.
+++
Perhaps this is precisely where Gorky’s tragedy lies.
The writer, who once saw the people on the margins of society better than anyone else, began at certain moments to see only what those in power wanted him to see.
But this tragedy is not Gorky’s alone.
It is the age-old tragedy in the relationship between the intellectual and power.
Power does not always imprison a writer.
Sometimes it gives him a house.
It awards prizes.
It provides a stage.
It prints his books in large print runs.
It celebrates his anniversary.
It names streets, cities, theatres, and institutes after him.
And one day, the writer realises: he no longer stands before power.
He stands at its side.
And this is the moment when the most difficult question of all arises: Can one, standing alongside power, say “No” to power?
+++
But another danger lurks here: judging Gorky from the comfortable armchair of the present.
We know how his time ended. He did not.
We see the extent of Stalinist terror in archives, in documents, and in the fates of millions of people.
He could not read the history books of the future.
He lived in the midst of history itself.
That does not absolve him of responsibility.
But it compels us to be just.
For the greatest moral presumption, when speaking of conscience, lies in automatically considering oneself braver than people who lived in the past.
The question “What should Gorky have done?” is easy to ask.
More difficult is this question: what would I have done in his place?
And even more difficult: am I not myself, today, in his place?
This question is not easy to answer—and perhaps that is precisely why it is worth dwelling on.
+++
For Gorky’s story did not end in 1936.
Only the backdrop changed.
Even today, there are writers who stand alongside those in power.
There are those who accept awards.
Those who choose to remain silent.
Those who leave their country.
Those who are arrested.
And those who tell themselves:
“If I stay here, at least I can help someone.”
Perhaps they really can.
Gorky, too, tried in some cases to help persecuted intellectuals.
But this idea harbours an invisible danger. Anyone who believes they are drawing closer to power in order to save others might one day find that they are defending that power itself.
This line is not crossed in a single day. The boundaries of conscience are not marked on any map. They shift a little every day.
Through a single silence.
Through an unwritten sentence.
Through a diluted truth.
By turning a blind eye to a lie.
Each time, the person tells themselves: “just this once.”
Then one “just this once” turns into another.
And one day, when he looks back, he no longer remembers when he crossed the line.
+++
Gorky should neither be canonised nor condemned.
It is easy to bow before a statue.
It is just as easy to smash it.
What is difficult is to see the person behind the statue.
To see his talent.
His faith.
His fame.
His fear.
His mistakes.
His conscience.
And the moments when his conscience was silent.
Being a great writer does not protect a person from moral failure.
Sometimes, on the contrary, it magnifies the extent of that failure.
The silence of an ordinary person may be audible only within a single room.
The silence of a great writer can be heard throughout an entire country.
+++
“Man—that sounds proud!”
Gorky’s words endure.
But his life adds another layer to this statement:
A human being should not merely sound proud. In the hour of greatest trial, he must remain human.
For the writer, the demand is even greater: to speak where others cannot. To doubt when everyone is forced to accept one and the same truth. To look at what is shown to him on this side of the door and to ask what is happening on the other side. And to preserve his own voice.
For power does not always demand that the writer lie.
Sometimes it is enough to leave a single truth unwritten.
Sometimes it rewards him.
Sometimes it intimidates him.
Sometimes it tests him through the fate of a loved one.
Sometimes it says nothing at all.
The writer remains silent of his own accord.
And perhaps it is precisely in this silence that the true test of conscience begins.
Did you enjoy this article? If so, please support our work a one-off donation or a monthly subscription via one of our subscription options. We’d be delighted!
Don’t want to miss any more articles on Literatur.Review? Then sign up for our newsletter free of charge!